Why Won’t My Car Key Come Out—and What to Do About It

It’s one of those moments that makes your heart sink: you turn off your car, reach to pull out the key, and it’s stuck. Don’t panic—this happens more often than you’d think, and there are a few common reasons.

Common Causes

1. Steering Wheel Lock:
   If the wheel is turned hard left or right when you shut off the vehicle, the ignition may lock. Try gently wiggling the steering wheel back and forth while turning the key slightly to release it.
   
   

2. Vehicle Not in Park:
   For automatic transmissions, the key won’t come out unless the gear selector is in “Park.” Double-check the shifter position and move it firmly into place.
   
   

3. Dirty Ignition Cylinder:
   Over time, dirt, debris, or key wear can cause sticking. A little Houdini or Tri-Flow Lube can help. Avoid liquid sprays that attract dust like WD-40 or graphite lubricants.
   
   

4. Worn Cylinder and/or Key:
   A worn or failing key or ignition switch can cause your key to get stuck or not turn properly. This usually requires professional service.
   
   

What You Can Do

If you’ve tried the steps above and your key still won’t come out, don’t force it—it can break inside the ignition, creating a much bigger problem. Instead, call a professional automotive locksmith. At Payson Lock & Key, we specialize in removing stuck keys, repairing ignitions, and cutting or programming replacements on-site—saving you a costly tow to the dealership.

🔹 Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why won’t my car key come out of the ignition?

The most common reasons are a locked steering wheel, the car not being fully in Park, or a worn ignition cylinder. Dirt or key wear can also cause sticking.

2. What should I do if my key is stuck?

Try gently wiggling the steering wheel left and right while turning the key, and make sure your shifter is completely in Park. If that doesn’t work, call a professional automotive locksmith—don’t force the key.

3. Can a locksmith remove a stuck car key?

Yes. A professional locksmith like Payson Lock & Key can safely extract the key, repair or replace the ignition, and even make or program a new key on-site—no towing required.

4. How can I prevent my car key from getting stuck again?

Avoid forcing the key, keep the ignition clean, and use a dry lubricant occasionally. If the key or ignition feels rough or loose, have it checked before it fails.

5. Is it cheaper to call a locksmith or go to a dealership?

A mobile locksmith is usually faster and more affordable. Payson Lock & Key comes to you, saving the cost of towing and long dealership waits.