What is the Right Safe For You?

Written By Jay Jones

A Utah Locksmith’s Guide to Choosing the Best Safe for Your Home or Business

Choosing the right safe is one of the most important security decisions you can make for your home or business. A safe protects more than just valuables, it protects documents, firearms, digital media, heirlooms, and peace of mind. Yet many Utah homeowners and business owners buy the wrong safe because they do not understand how safes are rated, how they are built, or what threats they are truly protecting against.

At Payson Lock & Key, we have helped customers across Utah including Payson, Salem, Spanish Fork, Park City, Heber, Fillmore, and surrounding Utah communities choose, install, open, move, and service safes since 1995. This guide explains the two main types of safes, what UL ratings really mean, and how to choose the right safe for your needs, not the one with the biggest marketing claims.

If you want personal guidance, visit our shop or call us for a free consultation.

The Two Main Types of Safes Explained

While safes come in many shapes and sizes, almost every safe falls into one of two main categories. Some safes combine features of both, but understanding the difference is critical.

1. Burglar-Resistant Safes

Burglar-resistant safes are designed to protect your valuables from theft. These safes focus on physical strength and forced-entry resistance.

They achieve protection through:

  • Thick steel in the door and body

  • Reinforced door frames

  • Hardened locking bolts

  • Drill-resistant plates

  • Relocking devices that activate during tampering

A quality burglar-resistant safe is built to withstand attacks using common tools such as pry bars, drills, saws, and in higher-rated safes, even torches and explosives.

These safes are ideal for protecting:

  • Cash

  • Jewelry

  • Firearms

  • Collectibles

  • Controlled medications

  • Sensitive business assets

For Utah homeowners concerned about break-ins, or businesses handling valuables, a burglar-resistant safe is often the first line of defense.

2. Fire-Resistant Safes

Fire-resistant safes are designed to protect the contents inside the safe from heat damage, not from theft.

These safes focus on:

  • Fire-resistant insulation

  • Sealed doors that expand during heat exposure

  • Materials that slow heat transfer

Fire safes are commonly used to protect:

  • Important documents

  • Birth certificates and passports

  • Deeds and titles

  • Insurance paperwork

  • Digital media and backups

Many people assume a fire safe also protects against theft. In reality, many fire safes offer little to no burglary protection. Some can be opened quickly with hand tools.

For customers in Utah, where wildfires and structure fires are real risks, fire protection is essential, but it must be matched with realistic expectations.

Why Many Safes Fail in Real-World Use

One of the most common problems we see is customers buying safes based on price or appearance rather than performance.

Common mistakes include:

  • Buying a fire safe thinking it protects against theft

  • Choosing a thin steel safe with no rating

  • Buying a safe too small for future needs

  • Installing a safe incorrectly or not anchoring it

  • Relying on manufacturer marketing instead of verified testing

A safe is only as good as its construction, rating, and installation.

Understanding UL Safe Ratings (This Part Matters)

Underwriters Laboratories (UL) is an independent testing organization that evaluates safes for burglary and fire resistance. A UL rating is one of the most reliable ways to know what a safe can actually withstand.

UL Burglary Ratings

UL burglary ratings measure how long a safe can resist a forced attack using specific tools.

Common burglary ratings include:

UL Residential Security Container (RSC)

  • Minimum entry-level rating

  • Resists a 5-minute attack using basic hand tools

  • Common in residential gun safes

UL TL-15

  • Resists a 15-minute attack using heavy tools

  • Suitable for higher-value home or business use

UL TL-30

  • Resists a 30-minute attack

  • Used by jewelry stores, pharmacies, and businesses

UL TRTL Ratings

  • Adds resistance to torches and explosives

  • Found in high-security commercial safes

If a safe does not list a UL burglary rating, it has not been independently tested, regardless of marketing claims.

UL Fire Ratings

UL fire ratings measure how long a safe can keep its internal temperature below a critical threshold.

Common fire ratings include:

  • 30 minutes

  • 1 hour

  • 2 hours

Some safes are also tested for:

  • Impact resistance (falling through floors during a fire)

  • Explosion resistance

A true UL fire rating is different from a manufacturer’s internal test. Always verify that the rating comes from UL.

Do You Need a Fire Safe, a Burglary Safe, or Both?

This depends on what you are protecting and where the safe will be installed.

Choose a Burglar-Resistant Safe If:

  • Theft is your primary concern

  • You store valuables, firearms, or cash

  • The safe is visible or accessible

  • You own a business

Choose a Fire-Resistant Safe If:

  • You store important documents or cash

  • You want protection from house fires

  • Theft risk is low

Choose a Dual-Rated Safe If:

  • You want balanced protection

  • You are protecting both valuables and documents

  • You want long-term peace of mind

A locksmith who works with safes can help you evaluate these risks honestly instead of overselling features you do not need.

Safe Size, Location, and Installation Matter

Choosing the right safe is not just about the rating.

Size

Most people underestimate how much space they need. Safes fill up quickly.

We recommend:

  • Buying larger than your current needs

  • Allowing room for growth

Location

Where the safe is installed affects its effectiveness.

Common locations include:

  • Closets

  • Basements

  • Garages

  • Offices

Visibility, anchoring options, and fire exposure all matter.

Installation

An unanchored safe can often be removed entirely.

Professional installation ensures:

  • Proper anchoring to concrete or framing

  • Level doors and bolt alignment

  • Full use of the safe’s security features

Why Work With a Locksmith When Choosing a Safe

A locksmith who specializes in safes understands:

  • UL ratings

  • Construction differences between brands

  • Real-world attack methods

  • Proper installation techniques

At Payson Lock & Key, we do not just sell safes, we service them. That experience gives us a practical perspective on which safes hold up over time and which ones fail.

We also provide:

  • Safe opening

  • Combination changes

  • Lock upgrades

  • Safe moving and relocation

Safe Solutions for Utah Homes and Businesses

We help customers across Utah choose safes for:

  • Homes

  • Retail stores

  • Offices

  • Churches

  • Schools

  • Industrial facilities

Every situation is different. A homeowner in Elk Ridge may need something different than a business owner in Spanish Fork or Payson.

Choosing the Right Safe Starts With the Right Questions

Before buying a safe, ask:

  • What am I protecting?

  • Theft, fire, or both?

  • Where will the safe be installed?

  • How long do I want this safe to last?

The right answers lead to the right safe.

Talk to a Local Safe Expert Before You Buy

A safe is a long-term investment. Buying the wrong one often leads to regret, replacement, or loss.

If you are in Payson or anywhere in central Utah, come in or call Payson Lock & Key. We will explain ratings, compare options, and help you choose a safe that fits your real needs—not just a price tag.

Serving Utah since 1995. Call today for expert guidance.

Talk to a Safe Security Expert

No sales pressure—just clear answers from experienced professionals.

Jay Jones
Previous

7 Important Reasons to Rekey Your House
Next

Keyless Entry for Businesses: Features and Benefits